Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Cultural Implications of Sex Ed: What are they really telling us?


Sex Ed 101: Be a Virgin
by Carli Rosati
WGSS 2000

I think we can all remember our sex education classes – not that there was really anything remarkable to remember. However, if there is one thing that stuck out is this idea of abstinence only education. While this is problematic within itself because it does not give the kind of education that teens really need, it also creates an attitude that is rather obsessed with the concept of virginity. Are you a girl? Yes. Are you married? No. Then you should be a virgin.

So what exactly is this obsession with virginity? Why should teens abstain from sex until married? Well, for girls, it’s going to be painful. Girls are not going to get any type of pleasure from it. In fact, it’s just going to be a bloody mess because your hymen will break. And really, is that an experience a girl should just share with anyone she find attractive? This is going to be a life-changing experience – going in a girl and coming out a woman. Sex should be saved for the right time unless you want to live a life of the morally corrupt.

There is a tremendous amount of consumerism that comes into play with this whole obsession with virgins. Feeney outlines how weddings are based on this idea of virginity: a white dress, a fancy ring. Women even go to the extent to get hymenoplasties, so that they can relive the experience of being a “virgin” on their wedding night with their husbands. There is a huge market on packets of red dye that can be inserted in the vagina to mimic the blood a virgin “ should” have.

These are the myths that are perpetuated in every facet of girls’ lives, and especially within the classroom. Do these even hold up? In Living Myths about Virginity from the Atlantic, Nolan Feeney debunks these myths. Sex does not always hurt. Actually, fewer than half of women bleed during their first time having sex. This myth about the pain associated with the hymen is so deeply engrained that sometimes even gynecologists have a strong misunderstanding about this thin layer of skin.

So what is sex like? Well, it varies. There is really no blanket statement to sum up how all women with different partners and different attitudes towards sex will experience their first time.

The bigger question is: What even is sex? Of course, in the classroom, they only discuss penis-in-vagina, vanilla, cis-gendered, heterosexual sex. But what about all the other ways people have sex without “actually” having sex? What exactly can you do before you are technically not a virgin? What exactly can a girl do before she loses it?

Well the answer to this is: there is no answer. There is no explicit definition of virginity and what it means to lose it. What about oral sex? Anal sex? Or just getting really handsy with a partner? What about masturbation? What about if you are with the same sex? The lines become easily blurred.

Greta Christina discusses her journey on understanding what sex is. Christina has done everything you can imagine, and sometimes, she gained more pleasure from being purely intimate with someone rather than PIV intercourse. She has experimented with men, with women, in a peep show, at sex parties and she still has no idea what her “number” would even be.

One thing that is certain is the way in which this language of virginity puts extreme burdens on women. It is gendered, and really, it’s violent. Feeney outlines the way in which Green explains in her YouTube videos that this language of “she lost her virginity” or “he popped her cherry” is violent. It makes women the passive partner in this sexual relationship, with men having something to gain as being domineering. What message does this send us?

All this talk about virginity and the expectation of women definitely does not promote a sex-positive society for teenagers to explore sex in a happy and healthy way. The virginity complex perpetuates harmful and inaccurate myths. It causes a negative outlook for sex. It does not allow for a dialogue about pleasure. It does not allow for a dialogue about the queer community.

Sex is not something to be feared. Sex is natural. Sex is a choice. Virginity, in itself, is a myth. Let’s promote some positive, understanding and real conversations about things that matter: consent and pleasure.


Class Sources: Greta Christina “Are we having sex or what?”

Word Count: 751

No comments:

Post a Comment